From our Brooklyn kitchen to your table, every batch is crafted with care. We believe great cookies start with simple ingredients, a lot of love, and a little bit of magic.
We bake in limited quantities throughout the day, ensuring every cookie you bite into is impossibly fresh, with a perfectly chewy center and crisp golden edge.
Thoughtfully designed for gifting, our signature boxes combine seasonal flavors and classics, wrapped with bakery paper and tied with a bow. Perfect for busy families and gift buyers.
We're a neighborhood gem inspired by the energy of Brooklyn. Our recipes nod to local flavors and we love being a part of your everyday moments and celebrations.
What Our Neighbors Say
From Brooklyn stoops to holiday tables, hear why our cookie boxes have become a local tradition.
"I sent a curated cookie box to my sister in Manhattan for her birthday and she called me crying happy tears. The packaging was so beautiful she didn't want to open it — but once she did, the cookies were gone in a day. Warm & Crumbly has become my go-to for every gift."
Sent a birthday box across the bridge — arrived fresh and perfect.
"With three kids, getting to the bakery is a whole production. Warm & Crumbly's online ordering is a lifesaver. We do the family sampler every other week and the kids get so excited when the box arrives. It's our little Friday ritual now."
Family sampler subscriber — Friday cookie night tradition.
"I ordered the holiday cookie box for our office party and it stole the show. Everyone kept asking where I got them. The gingerbread snaps and peppermint bark cookies were incredible — you can taste the real ingredients. Already planning my next order."
Holiday box for the team — stole the show at the party.
Every box is a Brooklyn moment — unwrap layers of homemade comfort, curated with care and ready to share.
Whether you're planning a celebration, curating the perfect gift, or simply craving something sweet, our Brooklyn-baked cookie boxes bring homemade comfort to every occasion. Let's create something crumbly together.